| Air Force |
14-1-1 |
2010: BYU won 2-1 |
| Alabama |
1-0-0 |
2019: BYU won 1-0 |
| Arizona |
11-2-0 |
2017: Arizona won 2-1 (OT) |
| Arizona State |
3-1-0 |
2005: BYU won 3-1 |
| Auburn |
1-0-0 |
2012: BYU won 1-0 |
| Baylor |
1-1-0 |
2014: Baylor won 2-1 |
| Boise State |
1-0-0 |
2019: BYU won 5-1 |
| Boston |
2-0-0 |
2001: BYU won 4-0 |
| Butler |
1-0-0 |
1998: BYU won 7-0 |
| California |
4-1-0 |
2015: BYU won 2-0 |
| Cal Poly |
4-0-2 |
2015: Tied 1-1 (2OT) |
| Cal State Fullerton |
7-0-2 |
2018: BYU won 1-0 (OT) |
| Cal State Northridge |
3-0-0 |
2002: BYU won 2-1 |
| Colgate |
2-0-0 |
2005: BYU won 2-0 |
| Colorado |
4-3-1 |
2017: Colorado won 3-0 |
| Colorado College |
2-1-0 |
2014: BYU won 4-0 |
| Connecticut |
1-1-0 |
2009: BYU won 1-0 |
| Creighton |
3-0-0 |
2000: BYU won 6-1 |
| Denver |
3-1-0 |
2016: BYU won 7-0 |
| Eastern Washington |
1-0-1 |
2005: Tied 0-0 (2OT) |
| Florida |
1-1-0 |
2003: Florida won 3-2 (OT) |
| Fresno State |
4-1-0 |
2006: Fresno State won 1-0 |
| George Mason |
1-0-0 |
2005: BYU won 4-0 |
| Georgia |
2-0-0 |
2008: BYU won 4-1 |
| Gonzaga |
12-0-0 |
2019: BYU won 3-0 |
| Harvard |
0-1-0 |
1999: Harvard won 1-0 |
| Hawai'i |
4-0-3 |
2009: Tied 0-0 (2OT) |
| Idaho |
1-0-0 |
2011: BYU won 5-0 |
| Idaho State |
8-2-0 |
2018: BYU won 10-0 |
| Iowa |
0-1-0 |
2003: Iowa won 3-2 (OT) |
| Kansas |
4-1-0 |
2019: BYU won 2-0 |
| Kansas State |
1-0-0 |
2019: BYU won 5-0 |
| Kentucky |
1-1-0 |
2003: BYU won 2-1 |
| Long Beach State |
8-3-0 |
2019: BYU won 3-0 |
| Louisiana State |
1-2-1 |
2014: LSU won 4-3 |
| Louisville |
1-0-0 |
2019: BYU won 3-0 |
| Loyola Marymount |
9-1-1 |
2019: BYU won 8-1 |
| Marquette |
2-2-1 |
2018: BYU won 3-0 |
| Massachusetts |
1-0-0 |
1998: BYU won 3-2 |
| Miami |
1-1-0 |
2011: Miami won 1-0 |
| Michigan |
1-1-1 |
2003: Tied 0-0 (2OT) |
| Michigan State |
4-0-0 |
2008: BYU won 2-0 |
| Milwaukee |
2-0-0 |
2000: BYU won 2-0 |
| Minnesota |
2-0-0 |
2001: BYU won 3-0 |
| Mississippi State |
1-0-0 |
2019: BYU won 2-1 |
| Montana |
7-3-0 |
2009: BYU won 2-1 |
| NC State |
1-0-0 |
2019: BYU won 3-0 |
| Nebraska |
2-4-1 |
2018: Tied 2-2 (2OT) |
| New Mexico |
15-4-2 |
2010: BYU won 1-0 |
| North Carolina |
0-1-0 |
2012: North Carolina won 2-1 (OT) |
| Northern Colorado |
1-0-0 |
1995: BYU won 1-0 |
| North Texas |
1-0-0 |
1996: BYU won 4-3 (OT) |
| Northwestern |
6-0-0 |
2010: BYU won 2-1 |
| Notre Dame |
1-0-0 |
2002: BYU won 3-2 |
| Ohio State |
1-0-1 |
2017: Tied 0-0 (2OT) |
| Oklahoma |
2-1-0 |
2016: BYU won 2-1 |
| Oklahoma State |
1-1-0 |
2011: Oklahoma State won 2-1 (OT) |
| Oregon |
4-0-1 |
2014: BYU won 2-1 |
| Oregon State |
3-0-0 |
2017: BYU won 3-0 |
| Pacific |
7-1-0 |
2019: BYU won 6-0 |
| Pacific (Oregon) |
3-0-0 |
2007: BYU won 1-0 |
| Penn State |
2-1-0 |
2017: Penn State won 3-1 |
| Pepperdine |
5-6-0 |
2019: BYU won 5-1 |
| Portland |
10-4-0 |
2019: BYU won 2-0 |
| Portland State |
2-1-0 |
1998: BYU won 3-1 |
| Rice |
1-0-1 |
2011: Tied 0-0 (2OT) |
| Saint Mary's |
9-0-1 |
2019: BYU won 8-0 |
| San Diego |
9-3-0 |
2019: BYU won 3-1 |
| San Diego State |
11-9-4 |
2010: BYU won 2-0 |
| San Francisco |
8-2-0 |
2019: BYU won 2-1 (2OT) |
| San Jose State |
5-1-0 |
1998: BYU won 2-0 |
| Santa Clara |
2-7-5 |
2019: Tied 2-2 (2OT) |
| South Alabama |
1-0-0 |
1995: BYU won 1-0 |
| South Carolina |
0-1-0 |
2016: South Carolina won 1-0 |
| Southern Methodist |
2-1-0 |
2016: BYU won 4-0 |
| Southern Utah |
3-0-0 |
2019: BYU won 7-0 |
| Stanford |
3-5-0 |
2019: Stanford won 5-1 |
| Tennessee |
3-1-0 |
2016: BYU won 5-2 |
| Texas |
2-3-0 |
2012: BYU won 5-0 |
| Texas A&M |
1-1-0 |
2019: BYU won 2-0 |
| Texas Christian |
9-1-0 |
2018: TCU won 2-1 |
| Tulsa |
2-0-0 |
1998: BYU won 3-2 |
| UC Irvine |
4-1-0 |
2019: BYU won 4-2 |
| UCLA |
2-2-1 |
2017: UCLA won 1-0 |
| UC Santa Barbara |
2-0-0 |
2009: BYU won 2-0 |
| UNLV |
16-1-2 |
2016: BYU won 2-0 |
| USC |
2-3-3 |
2008: Tied 1-1 (2OT) (4-2 PK for USC) |
| Utah |
23-7-2 |
2019: BYU won 2-0 |
| Utah State |
13-0-0 |
2016: BYU won 3-1 |
| Utah Valley |
5-0-0 |
2019: BYU won 1-0 |
| UTEP |
1-0-0 |
1997: BYU won 7-1 |
| Villanova |
0-0-1 |
2003: Tied 0-0 (2OT) (5-3 PK for BYU) |
| Virginia |
0-1-0 |
2001: Virginia won 3-2 (OT) |
| Virginia Tech |
1-0-0 |
2008: BYU won 2-0 |
| Wake Forest |
0-1-0 |
2001: Wake Forest won 3-2 (OT) |
| Washington |
4-1-2 |
2012: BYU won 3-1 |
| Washington State |
4-2-2 |
2016: BYU won 2-1 (2OT) |
| Weber State |
15-0-1 |
2013: BYU won 4-0 |
| West Virginia |
1-0-0 |
2009: BYU won 1-0 (OT) |
| William & Mary |
0-2-0 |
2009: William & Mary won 1-0 (OT) |
| Wisconsin |
2-0-0 |
2007: BYU won 1-0 |
| Wyoming |
15-1-0 |
2010: BYU won 4-1 |
